What is the flaw in the argument made by the friend about sending his son to Harvard?

Discover the Academic Games Propaganda Section E Test. Study with our quizzes that include multiple choice questions, hints, and explanations. Prepare for success today!

The identification of the flaw in the argument as a composition fallacy indicates that the friend is incorrectly assuming that what is true for a group (in this case, Harvard as a prestigious university) must also be true for an individual member of that group (his son). This line of reasoning often overlooks individual circumstances or capabilities, suggesting that just because Harvard is an esteemed institution, attending it will automatically lead to success for every student who enrolls.

In examining a composition flaw, it’s crucial to understand that generalizations about a group do not necessarily apply to each individual within that group. Just as not every person from a prestigious university will excel or embody the traits associated with that institution, not every student will thrive under the same educational conditions or achieve their goals merely due to the name on their diploma.

This reasoning illustrates the importance of considering personal merits, challenges, and fit for a specific educational environment rather than relying solely on the reputation of the institution itself.

Subscribe

Get the latest from Examzify

You can unsubscribe at any time. Read our privacy policy